Dye Free

Custom Sugar

Cookie Artist

Decorative cookies shaped like the state of West Virginia, decorated with blue, pink, green, and yellow icing, featuring the text 'WVU Medicine' and floral designs.

using only Plant-Based Natural Food Dye!!

Katie- Founder and Owner of Sugar + Spice Cookie Co. LLC

Sugar + Spice Cookie Co. LLC is a charming, custom sugar cookie home bakery in Wheeling, WV, specializing in creating artificial dye FREE, delicious, beautifully crafted cookies for every special occasion in your life!

Get in touch

Illustration of a cute sugar cube and cinnamon stick with faces and limbs, standing on a purple line.

Heart-shaped decorated cookie with pink and white icing, featuring a flower design.

Assorted ocean-themed cookies in various shapes, including a shell, a starfish, fish, a crab, and one with the word 'baby' written in pink icing, all on a white background.

Decorative cookies with patriotic or celebratory themes, including rainbows, stars, fireworks, and plaques that say "Congratulations Diego!" and "USA."

How It Works

Planning a special event and looking for custom sugar cookies to make it unforgettable? Simply fill out the order form on our “Order Form/ Contact Information” page and we’ll begin designing the perfect cookies for your occasion.

Have a quick question before filling out the order form? Please feel free to contact me by phone or email listed at the bottom of this page.

To ensure ample time for preparation and perfection, orders of 1-3 dozen must be placed 1 week in advance, and larger orders must be placed 2 weeks in advance.*

*Orders can be expedited within 3-5 days and may incur an additional fee of $10/dozen. (based on availability)

Screenshot of a positive customer review for cookies, praising their detailed design and customer service, mentioning both mother and daughter.

Customer Reviews:

Screenshot of a Facebook post praising Sugar + Spice Cookie Co. about their cookies' appearance and taste.

Screenshot of a review by Diana praising cookies she ordered for her daughter's birthday party, highlighting the beautiful designs and easy communication.

Screenshot of a Facebook recommendation post for Sugar + Spice Cookie Co. praising Katie's cookies.

Screenshot of a Google review for a cookie shop with 5 stars, posted 3 weeks ago, praising the freshness and quality of the cookies, with perfect scores for food, service, and atmosphere.